Prof Alex German holds the position of Royal Canin Professor of Small Animal Medicine at the University of Liverpool. He is well known for his studies on obesity prevention in dogs and cats in the UK.
Together with Prof Richard Barrett-Jolley, they published a study in May 2024 that has increased confidence in the apparent benefits of plant-based diets for dogs.
The study reanalysed data within a major published 2022 study of 2,536 dogs – the largest published study within this field. That study concluded that the healthiest and least hazardous dog foods were nutritionally-sound vegan diets.
Owner opinions of health were included in this study, which may not always be reliable. For example, owners committed to feeding vegan or meat-based diets might sometimes fail to recognise or report subsequent health problems and they would hold definite bias towards the diet they had chosen when answering questions.
Prof German’s new research focused specifically on subjective dog owner opinions of health, in contrast to the original study which examined seven general indicators of illness, including more objective data such as the prevalence of medication use, therapeutic diet use, and the frequency of veterinary visits.
The original study also analysed the reported assessments of vets concerning dog health, as well as the prevalence of 22 of the most common health disorders in dogs. It also considered prior studies documenting hazards (pathogens and nutritional imbalances) associated with raw meat diets.
The new study by Prof German used additional statistical methods, including machine learning, to analyse owner opinions of health. It found these were minimally affected when vegan diets were fed.
A fresh row has erupted over the merits of vegan pet diets after new analysis argued there was only a “minimal” link between the approach and animals’ health.
‘Negligible’
But the new paper argued that diet choice was a “negligible” factor in canine health, with age, frequency of veterinary visits and receiving medication found to be the most important indicators instead.
That conclusion is based on the development of two new variables based on whether either any health problem or a significant illness was reported in individual cases.
Prof Alex German, said the suggestion that vegan diets were healthier than alternatives was “not accurate”, because the original study’s reliance on survey data meant that it could only indicate “a possible correlation and not causality”.
‘Nuanced insights’
His co-author, Richard Barrett-Jolley, argued that the current approach provided “more nuanced insights” on the subject than the earlier analysis.
Prof Barrett-Jolley said: “Crucially, we cannot draw a firm conclusion as to what diet type is actually best for dogs; this was never possible given the nature of the original dataset and study design.
“However, we can conclude that variables other than dog diet are more strongly associated with owner opinions about the health of their dog.”
Swift response
But the paper’s publication on 15 May prompted a swift response, which branded the new research as a scientific attempt to “undermine” vegan diets and suggested it had backfired.
Prof Andrew Knight, the lead author of the original study, said: “I was relieved to see confirmation that feeding vegan diets had minimal impact on owner opinions about health. This increases my confidence in the reliability of the owner opinions we analysed.
“The large number of health parameters we studied, and the very large number of dogs included, provide a high degree of confidence in our results.”
In response, Prof German described the confirmation claim as “surprising”.
‘Ecological grounds’
Prof Knight also argued that what he described as “substantial dietary change” was now essential on ecological grounds, following a paper published last year that calculated that more than 450 million more people could be fed through food energy savings if all the world’s dogs were put on to a vegan diet.
Could our dogs or cats trigger an avian influenza pandemic?
As our memories of the last COVID 19 disappear, the potential for another pandemic looms and pets could play a role in transmitting it
Plant-based vs Insect-based dog food
Insect Protein-Based Diets as Potential Risk of Allergy in Dogs, and Higher Cost
Fermented Protein Pet Food – the Future?
Is precision fermentation our future way to feed not only our pets, but ourselves too? Yes it most certainly is!
Cultivated Chicken Dog Food in Pets At Home!
Cell-based meat and vegan ingredients represent the future of pet food. These are the only ingredients that are good for pets, ‘food’ animals and the planet.
Using microbial protein for the very first time in dog treats!
This first-of-its-kind protein is derived from bacteria that have been consumed by humans for centuries in foods such as kimchi, kefir, and sauerkraut
BVA says it is possible to feed dogs plant-based
The British Veterinary Association (BVA) has ended its opposition to (nutritionally-sound) vegan diets for dogs
Who is MARS Petcare?
How did they go from producing Snickers, Mars, Bounty bars, Pedigree, Royal Canin and Whiskas to be the fourth largest privately held company in the US?
The Great Protein Debate – Beef or Beans?
Dr Sue Paterson, RCVS President and Senior Vice President of the European Society of Veterinary Dermatologists interviews Dr Arielle Griffiths about Sustainable Pet Foods
The longest, most comprehensive peer-reviewed study so far!
Domestic dogs maintain positive clinical, nutritional, and haematological health outcomes when fed a commercial plant-based diet for a year. Peer reviewed and published in PLOS ONE
Reasons Why Dog Owners Stop Feeding Raw Meat-Based Diets
The latest paper from April 2024 makes an astounding 85 papers against the use of raw feeding in our dogs
UK’s first meat cultivated cat food to launch!
The world’s first cans of cat food made with cultivated chicken to be sold in 2024 at Pets At Home!
Plant Ingredients in Dog Food
An enormously positive article about the use of plant-based proteins in pet food written by PhD Veterinary Scientist Jelena Suran in February 2024
